-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512


# 10 Reasons Not to Give Animals Rights
by: Owen Gunden

2014-09-25

tags: animal rights, vegan
* * *

*Imagine that it's before the abolition of slavery, and you are a normal
person. One day, you wake up and realize that slavery is immoral. You begin to
see everything differently. You feel compelled to speak out, but alas, nobody
wants to hear what you have to say. When you raise the issue with others, they
dismiss your concerns with one or more of the following 10 reasons.*

The following [10 reasons not to abolish
slavery](http://fee.org/articles/ten-reasons-not-to-abolish-slavery/) are being
used around the net by liberty proponents, towards the abolition of government.
I found them also to be eerily similar to arguments opposing animal rights.

1. It's natural.

  * "Slavery is natural. People differ, and we must expect that those who are
    superior in a certain way--for example, in intelligence, morality,
    knowledge, technological prowess, or capacity for fighting--will make
    themselves the masters of those who are inferior in this regard."

  * "Raising animals for food is natural. After all, lions eat meat. Species
    differ, and we must expect that those who are more intelligent, make moral
    decisions, or are just plain stronger will make themselves masters of the
    inferior species."

2. It's tradition.

  * "Slavery has always existed."

  * "People have been eating animals since ancient history."

3. Everybody does it.

  * "Every society on earth has slavery." The unspoken corollary is that every
    society must have slavery.

  * "Every society on earth eats animals, therefore every society must continue
    to eat animals." (Although the premise is debatable, it's moot because the
    argument is not valid anyway.)

4. It's for their own good.

  * "The slaves are not capable of taking care of themselves."

  * "The animals are not capable of taking care of themselves."

5. It's for their own survival.

  * "Without masters, the slaves will die off." This idea is the preceding one
    pushed to the extreme.

  * "Without animal agriculture, the cows/pigs/chickens/sheep/goats/etc. will
    die off."

6. No really, it's better for them.

  * "Where the common people are free, they are worse off than the slaves."

  * "Living on a farm is a better deal for the animals than the alternative.
    They are fed and sheltered on farms, unlike in the wild."

7. Putting a stop to it would be too disruptive.

  * "Getting rid of slavery would occasion great bloodshed and other evils." In
    the United States many people assumed that the slaveholders would never
    permit the termination of the slave system without an all-out fight to
    preserve it.

  * "Ceasing to eat animals will cause great economic hardship to the farmers."
    (ok, this one doesn't quite compare, I haven't really heard anyone argue
    that there would be "great bloodshed". Does "I would have to give up
    cheeseburgers" count?).

8. They would run amuck.

  * "Without slavery the former slaves would run amuck, stealing, raping,
    killing, and generally causing mayhem."

  * "Without farms, the animals would run amuck, stealing from suburban
    gardens, crowding the streets, and generally causing mayhem."

9. It's not practical.

  * "Trying to get rid of slavery is foolishly utopian and impractical; only a
    fuzzy-headed dreamer would advance such a cockamamie proposal."

  * "Veganism is a foolishly idealistic and impractical, misguided attempt at
    showing compassion. It's just not realistic."

10. Focus on welfare, not abolition.

  * "Forget abolition. A far better plan is to keep the slaves sufficiently
    well fed, clothed, housed, and occasionally entertained and to take their
    minds off their exploitation."

  * "Forget veganism. A far better plan is to focus on welfare reforms; keep
    the animals sufficiently well treated, 'humanely' confined, exploited, and
    slaughtered."


The only ethical position on animal rights is not to use their lives and bodies
for our own pleasure, habit, fashion, financial gain, or any other reason. This
is called living in alignment with our values, a.k.a. living a vegan lifestyle.


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=
=BW7U
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----